How long is too long...?

Vii_Rms

New Member
I started writing a dark romance fantasy, and I'm already 66 chapters in. Each chapter, I have it going from 1,500 to 4,000. Multiple POV and it's a lot of points which are necessary for the story. There is a climax in the middle around Chapter 50. Should I cut this novel in half? Right now I am at 167,799 words, without heavy editing or even coming close to my ending.
 
In the realm of dark romance fantasy, longer books tend to be all right, however, I'd say you're running into needing to turn it into a few books instead of just one. If you're at chapter 66 and you just hit the middle in chapter 50, that's a lot. If it's a first draft, I could see maybe editing would help bring it down a bit, but that would be a task in and of itself to make sure the story still functions if you cut big pieces.

I'd say get it finished and then see where you're at, and maybe if you're not sure of where to make edits, ask for a beta. Someone who can help you maybe find places that aren't cohesive, and so on and so forth.

Either way, that's impressive. Good luck to you on your writing quest.
 
Fantasy and sci-fi can get away with being door-stoppers, especially epic fantasy and sprawling space operas. However, 167k and no end in sight is well outside the norm for debut fantasy romance.

When I was starting out, the conventional wisdom was that agents weren’t interested in debuts more than 100k in most genres and 120k at the absolute most for fantasy or sci-fi. Even then, your odds were worse in that 100-120k stretch.

Now, those limits tend to be lower. I’m hearing 90k a lot, with 100k as a stretch. So if you’re shooting for traditional publication, this is almost certainly too big for one book.

Personally, I’d finish your book (a massive achievement in its own right) and then worry about all this later. Alpha and beta readers could help identify what works, what doesn’t, where it could be condensed, etc. and then developmental and line editors could help trim it down. Edits would probably need to be pretty ruthless to cut it down to a marketable word count, though.

If you’re after self-publication, word count is less of a concern, though at a certain point you’ll run into physical limitations when it comes to what can be bound in a single paperback or hardcover. Also worth noting large word counts are common to beginners and sometimes indicate bloat, so I’d still commit to detailed edits to be sure it’s in the best shape it can be.
 
Depends on what you want ro do with it.
If you want to get it traditionally published, a manuscript over 100k (even for tantasy) will get rejected. Agents do not want to invest in a high wordcount debut author (unless they have a strong social media following who will buy the book, and/or the premise is unique enough).
There is a debut fantasy writer whos first book was close to your wordvount. He firat published it on his blog a chapter at a time. It got super popular. Then an agent tapped him to publish it.

If you self publish.... publish it however you want, but keep in mind, the prince to print it increases with the wordcount.

Mine is 150k.
Isplit it up into 3 parts and am going to self publish it as ebooks.
 
Back
Top