Why do you, or don't you, take part in writing contests?

[defaux]

I participate in the contests regularly - in fact, I deliberately do so at every opportunity, both here and over on dotcom. For me, it forms part of my discipline. Between the two I get 2 short stories and 2 flash pieces (plus the 4th, and an occasional attempt at poetry or whatever else might be going on.) That means it pushes me to output roughly one piece of fiction per week. = Habit, deadlines, exercising the writing muscles regularly. Like marathon training, I ran 5k every day, and gradually worked my way up, not just going out to run 42k cold.

I enjoy the challenge of the prompts, particularly when it pushes me into something that I wouldn't choose. It encourages me to try to create inspiration from the ether, rather than simply waiting (hoping) for it to strike. I often combine the contest prompts with a personal growth challenge from my own coaching process, like try this one in a different POV, or a new genre or whatever, to stretch the skills into something I haven't yet attempted. Sometimes I discover things I unexpectedly like.

It is a low stakes environment that allows me to try out new and different things (characters, genres, styles, voice, etc.) on an unsuspecting audience (sorry, not sorry) without concern for them not working out. It's an avenue for learning and growth. I really enjoy reading everyone's interpretations of the prompt, seeing how they have composed their ideas, and what they have done better than I - then asking myself, how can I do this differently, better, next time?

And yes, it builds the portfolio. I now have some 30 odd stories written over the past 6 months, of which the best may be selected for submitting to publication (a goal for this year). All of this is my self-prescribed pathway towards completing and hopefully one day publishing the novel which is responsible for getting me started. I also have at least a couple more concepts for novels that derive from short pieces I wrote, and possible world building texture or context where I might fit some of this ideas together or within an existing novel concept. So it is all progression, of a kind. At least I hope it is.

And let's not forget the bling. Winning is certainly nice validation, but a lot of the time I'm happy to receive a single vote as evidence that I have not completely failed. Of course there are many talented writers competing, and it's actually validating just to be in the same company. Not being abjectly laughed out of the club does something passively positive for my impostor syndrome.

Oh and @Homer Potvin I concur. I don't see anyone having an issue if you wished to participate.

 

[Homer Potvin]

Qaddafi medals

I think I just shit myself laughing... might be the first Qaddafi reference in WF history.

 

[Naomasa298]

I enjoy the challenge of the prompts, particularly when it pushes me into something that I wouldn't choose. It encourages me to try to create inspiration from the ether, rather than simply waiting (hoping) for it to strike. I often combine the contest prompts with a personal growth challenge from my own coaching process, like try this one in a different POV, or a new genre or whatever, to stretch the skills into something I haven't yet attempted. Sometimes I discover things I unexpectedly like.

I like that. I write personal development pieces too, to try out things I've never tried, although I tend not to do it in contests. I can't sustain that level of output over such a long period though, I still have to take my time.

I reckon, the hardest thing to accept is that, when you produce a piece like that and you don't win, or get lots of praise, you think it failed. I think you'll agree with me that, that's not true. Sometimes, it needs refinement, but other times, it just didn't land with that audience.

 

[defaux]

I reckon, the hardest thing to accept is that, when you produce a piece like that and you don't win, or get lots of praise, you think it failed. I think you'll agree with me that, that's not true. Sometimes, it needs refinement, but other times, it just didn't land with that audience.

You are certainly correct. My comment about failing is probably more self-deprecating than anything. It can certainly feel like that when you allow the votes to be the entirety of feedback you absorb. But, an entry can still be good and not draw votes, when there is another entry that is simply excellent that pulls the votes for that month. Some folks do leave comments as well, at least for ones they liked, which can be encouraging.

Personally, I would love there to be more in the way of discussion around the entries and results, particularly given this is my chosen primary exhibit of work - not necessarily workshop level, but a simple feedback covering what worked and what didn't. Still, I understand that is not everyone's idea of a good time. I usually try to leave a small comment on for each entry, though I'm uncertain whether even a surface level or critique would be welcome in this context. And therein likely lies the problem.

It's fine if this is deemed not the venue for such discussion, I recognise that turning the contest into another workshop might be detrimental. For me it would add value, for others it might become more intimidating. But I'm also unsure the etiquette around popping over to the workshop and asking for feedback on a contest entry.

 

[Naomasa298]

Personally, I would love there to be more in the way of discussion around the entries and results, particularly given this is my chosen primary exhibit of work - not necessarily workshop level, but a simple feedback covering what worked and what didn't. Still, I understand that is not everyone's idea of a good time. I usually try to leave a small comment on for each entry, though I'm uncertain whether even a surface level or critique would be welcome in this context. And therein likely lies the problem.

I don't think we're supposed to do that here, because not everyone wants feedback on their entry. If they do, they can post it in the workshop. I guess there must have been some issues on the OG. That was the policy there, anyway, so I assume it's continuing here. I do agree tough, I reckon it's a good idea though, but I'm not gonna argue with the forum policy. I dunno, maybe people could specify if they don't want feedback or discussion on it.

 

[Luxuria]

I think you worry far too much about that. Readers aren't really going to bat an eyelid about historical incest. If you want to write a story about Oedipus and his mum, we all know it, and it simply doesn't land as "incest". It lands as "mythology". Real, historical cases will land as "history". Watch HBO/BBC's Rome. Octavian (Augustus) is seduced by his sister, and that was primetime TV. The only pushback you ever really get is nationalist pushback when you say something "disrespectful" towards one country's cherished historical figure, like, I dunno, turn Vera Lynn into a transgender dominatrix or something

Okay, thank you. Then, I will try and participate in the Writing Contests, when I can. (I have already thought of a few of the prompts.) And okay, cool. Good to know you all are a chill group.

I've seen the mythological Gemini twins in a same-sex incestuous relationship.

I have heard of that being a thing. Makes sense to me, but not my personal favorite Greek Myth Pairing.

I can't speak for them, obviously, but what seems to bother the mods most is explicit erotica, doesn't matter if it's Zeus and Hera, or Peter and Jane. You can always PM them and ask, or send them the story to see if it breaks the rules. I suspect you'd be surprised.

More or less. It's more about being overly gratuitous than anything else. Sex, violence, suicide, and incest are all fine subject matter within reason, but don't make it a masturbatory thing, like you're jacking off while writing it. Can't help you if you don't the difference between tasteful literature and self-indulgent fantasy.

@Naomasa298 - I understand and I think my fear is that I will post something and get insta-banned, because I didn't read the room. I won't be posting any erotica or anything, but I would like the mods to just let me know if something I write goes too far. Which, from what I said, I doubt it will. But I just love this community so much that I don't want to accidentally get kicked out.

@Homer Potvin - No, it's not at all 'erotic'. I can promise you that. But good to know. I will try and use my own judgement. And haha, you're right. You'd be no help there. Hah.

Essentially, anything that breaks forum rules is probably self-serving garbage anyway. Aside from erotica which is intentionally pornographic and gratuitous.

Okay, good to know! Because I hope my stuff doesn't come off as self-servicing garbage. Haha.

 

[Set2Stun]

I never imagined I'd become a flash/short story writer. I began my journey by writing my first novel - but it turned out I still needed to get a lot more words down on the page before I'd actually become good at writing. The contests really helped me with this. Great practice, and something to keep one's sword sharp while working on all the querying-related nonsense for the novels.

I'm glad I went down this path on the old site for so many reasons. The main benefit these days is to have writing credits that I can proudly list in my queries and on my author bios and sites. Have to imagine I'm getting a boost, whether it's a potential customer of my book, or someone evaluating a query or submission - "Oh, this dude got published by Nature Magazine and Sci Phi Journal? He's definitely a pro."

It wasn't easy to get to that point of course. Took me a good long while to secure my first contest win, and after the voting I'd often go right to the workshop to find out how I could've tightened up my story. I know it's different for everybody, but I can't recommend participating in the contests enough !

 

[ps102]

I used to be very active in 2023 myself. I can't check because the old forum is dead, but I think I maintained a 14-month participation streak from late 2022 to early 2024. But my activity lessened since then until it dwindled to nothingness. I've not participated in a single contest since the creation of the new forum.

There are reasons. I talked about this a lot in the old forum, though almost not at all here. Basically, my self-esteem is non-existent. I have to fight constant thoughts of self-belittlement. I didn't just stop participating in contests, I stopped writing altogether. Aside from some things here and there, I basically did no writing in 2024.

Thankfully, the Tavern forum RPG got me writing again in 2025. Since I had nothing else, I put all of my attention on it, and have had immense fun. It has been super nice to be excited about a story again. I still dislike my writing but I try to overlook it. We're near the end now and I'm excited to see how it all turns out.

I do miss the forum contests. The great prompts made me write some genuinely nice stories. And during that 14-month streak, I did learn a lot about my own writing skills by competing against others who were a gazillion times better than me. It was actually a great highlight of my writing life. I remember I couldn't shut up about it back then. I'd often vouch just how great these were for those starting it out, and how much they helped me. And those few times I did win after so much effort? It was pretty glorious for low-confidence me to win.

My beliefs are the same now as they were then. If you want to improve yourself, join the contests and combine it with good use of the workshop. You will seriously learn a lot.

I'm not quite ready to enter again. But I would like to soon... maybe after the RPG finishes. I've learned that I can only really focus on so much at a time thanks to my autism. At least, I should get back to voting. By coincedence, I did actually read this month's entries to the short story contest and found myself genuinely surprised by a certain one.