I don't think it's weird. That's been the case for me throughout much of my life, especially the early bits.
I'm a pretty damn social person, when in the right mood. I love the occasional party, cherish deep conversation, enjoy quality time, all of that. I adore meeting new and interesting people and having a good time with them, if only for a night. On the other hand I have a pretty spicy form of social anxiety, and a huge need for long periods of solitude and introspection.
I've had more than one external bestie over the ages. Those are beautiful, rich, invaluable relationships. But they're tough to maintain and very hard to find. It's an incredible stroke of luck that I've had even one, much less several. And I haven't always honored them the way I should have. What's more, when I get that deeply immersed in relating to another person, I find that I lose touch with and neglect myself to some extent. Like, I can identify completely with the relationship and practically disappear into it. When a relationship like that suddenly ends, its a bit of a doomsday situation. So yeah, there's an element of fear that comes with that sort of intimacy. A certain kind of death that follows the dissolution thereof.
That isn't to say my relationship with myself is always a dance on roses. I can be pretty shitty even to people I love and care about, and that goes doubly for myself. It's all well and good being your own best friend, but I don't always get along with me. I can give myself such a hard time. I leave dirty dishes in the sink, and all that.
This raises some interesting questions about identity, but that's a whole other topic.
But yeah. Your relationship with yourself is the only one you're guaranteed to keep your whole life, so might as well try to make the best of it. You can grow apart from other people, but you can only grow with yourself. Staying deeply connected to your inner life, and being genuinely kind to yourself and having your own back in all things is great and important. I think it's one of the deepest forms of intimacy one can experience on planet Earth.
But, just as I have a way of losing myself in relationships with others, I find it's way too easy to crawl all the way up myself. I'm not ready to be a closed system, an island unto myself. I'm fortunate enough to have a great family and quite a lot of friends, even if none of my current relationships are what I would call "deep". They're sort of compartmentalized, limited in scope. I have my Nerdy Friends™ that I play games and talk about books and movies with, I have my Party People™ that I go for drinks and shenanigans with, and my That One Weird Fucking Wildcard Guy™ who serves me up fresh eccentric bullshit on the daily. I have a family that supports me, that picks me up and dusts me off when I need it. I love them all and would feel impoverished without them.
But a best friend, a true confidant, someone who's always there sharing in everything I do? That one person who understands you on a fundamental level and accepts you nonetheless? Haven't had that in a long time. Not sure I ever did, but I at least imagined it now and again. So I'm trying to be that to myself, while still being out and about in the world the way a real human being might. Still a bit of a fucking balancing act, that. My self-relationship isn't all it could be, it's a bit toxic and abusive at times, but I'm working on it. I'm considering couple's counseling. Won't they just be bloody surprised when I show up on my lonesome?
The long and short of it is... Well, you can easily see the long just up there, I kinda went on and on there. While I have a pretty insistent yearning for love, community, fellowship and all of that, I'm also really picky about how those things manifest. And it seems to me those are more often than not built on sand. That's just my perspective. I'm the sort of person who's always in flux, and I'm not sure I have it in me to put down deep roots anywhere. Belonging to something, anything, has always seemed to me like a limiting condition. It's more in my nature to flow free and briefly alight in this or that setting, to see what's up in a given place and then flap onwards, maybe to return one day but possibly not. I don't know how to keep a bestfriendship alive in that context.
And who's been with me for that entire ride, and will be with me on every ride to come? Why, it's only myself! Fucking hooray, besties until the end of time.
And I will say that a lot of the people I meet seem to be pretty shallow and one-note. I don't do shallow and one-note. In most cases that is probably a quality of me not having the opportunity or interest to get to know them very well, but maybe not. Maybe a lot of folks out there are just stuck deep in one or maybe two grooves. Hard to say. And they're no worse for it, bless them. They're beautiful in their way. It's just not for me.
Thanks for posting this thread. It triggered some self-reflection that I seem to have sorely needed.